Gather Your Ingredients For This Papa John’s Garlic Sauce Copycat Recipe
The ingredients you need for this Papa John’s garlic sauce copycat recipe are probably items you already have on hand unsalted butter, salt, garlic powder, and onion powder. Seriously, you don’t need anything else. Carli says she prefers using unsalted butter to the salted version in everything she cooks, as this enables her to control the salt content in her meals. That said, if you don’t have unsalted butter on hand, salted will do just fine.
Also, if you prefer to use fresh garlic and onion , Carli says that you can, but you’re really just making life harder on yourself. The powdered versions easily blend into the sauce, while minced garlic and onion will leave chunks in the finished version. You can always remove the chunks, but ultimately, the flavor won’t be that different, and the whole recipe will take longer to make.
How Is Papa Johns Stuffed Crust Made
The new crust is made up of the 6 ingredients you already know and love in the Papa Johns recipe book flour, water, sugar, soybean oil, salt and yeast. But then its hand stuffed with extra cheese, topped with the signature pizza sauce, more cheese, and then baked to perfection with your favorite pizza toppings.
Editors. 9 Last Updated. 4 days ago Users. 5
Can You Cook A Pizza On The Cardboard
To ensure the safety of everyone, refrain from baking or reheating pizza on cardboard. When you cook your pizza with cardboard on it, either your pizza will be crispy and delicious without burning the carton, or the cardboard will smoke tremendously and even catching on fire that would ruin your pizza night.
Don’t Miss: Lemongrass Basil Simmer Sauce
Can I Use Real Butter
Of course! You can definitely use real butter here if you want to, and it would be delicious.
I suggest using salted butter if you go this route.
To make your garlic dip, melt the margarine in the microwave or on the stove top.
Next, whisk in the garlic powder to taste.
If you are a garlic lover like me, you may be pouring a whole lot more in there!
You just really cant got wrong with this easy recipe.
Pizza night at home just got a lot more delicious!
Hungry for more copycat recipes? You must try our homemade Chick-fil-a sauce!
Be sure to pin this recipe for later and follow for all the latest delicious recipes!
Did you make this recipe? Be sure to leave a star rating below!
Papa Johns Garlic Sauce Is Now Available In Gallon Jugs
Because some people cant get enough of the stuff.
The people who love Papa Johns garlic sauce REALLY love Papa Johns garlic sauce.
I LOVE Papa John’s garlic sauce!! I think I could practically drink the stuff! wrote Genius Kitchen contributor @Manda, who posted a DIY recipe for PAPA JOHN’S GARLIC DIPPING SAUCE that other contributors to the recipe-sharing site have rated an average of 4.5 stars.
So, you know, even those of us whove never even considered dipping a perfectly good as-is pizza crust in a combo of buttery-oily-salty-garlickyness can see that devotion to the sauce is clearly a thing and that some people would apparently drink the stuff by the gallon if given half a chance.
Well, now those people have the chance.
Papa Johns has just announced that it is making its iconic garlic sauce available for purchase in XL jugs starting this Friday, May 11.
This is not a drill. Papa Johns garlic sauce lovers now have the opportunity to incorporate their beloved garlic sauce into every meal. So whether youre dipping a slice of Papa Johns pepperoni za or whatever else you like to douse in a golden bath of deliciousness , Papa Johns has got you covered, a spokesperson for the brand told FN Dish via email.
The limited-edition gallon-jugs of garlic sauce will sell for $20 and will be available, for a limited time, in select cities and online, the pizza chain says.
You May Like: Texas Pete Hot Sauce Walmart
Does Papa Johns Pizza Sauce Have Garlic In It
The warm, buttery sauce goes perfectly with pizzas and breadsticks. Papa Johns uses mostly soybean oil and water in their sauce with the flavorings coming from salt and garlic. They use beta carotene for coloring and a whole lot of other ingredients to maintain the sauce consistency and freshness.
What Can You Dip Pizza In Besides Ranch
Below are some of the best options you should try.
- Mayonnaise. This is one of the most loved pizza dips that are sure to pamper each and every taste buds of the person tasting it.
- Tomato Ketchup. Tomato ketchup is one of the most common sauces that are used to boost up the taste of a pie.
- Barbecue Sauce.
- Garlic Paste.
Also Check: Where To Buy Rao’s Sauce
Former Papa Johns Manager Shares Recipe For Dipping Sauce Says To Never Order This One Pizza
Shutterstock / Ken Wolter
If Im ordering pizza delivery its 99.999% going to be something local. If I am forced to eat from one of the main pizza chains in America I prefer Hungry Howies because theyve got that awesome butter cheese and/or garlic crush add-on, but I cant deny my love for Papa Johns. If Im at an NFL/MLB game theres a decent chance Ill be ordering a personal Papa Johns pizza because of that crack sauce .
I was a bit worried when I came across a headline on Food& Wine saying theres a Papa Johns pizza out there which a former PJs manager said you should never ever order. As it turns out, Id never order this pizza to begin with so Im cool. But I cant speak for you and what types of pizza you eat. This former Papa Johns managers comments came in a Reddit AMA several months ago, heres the Q& A exchange which caught my attention:
iwas99x:What items are so seldom wondered that you wonder why they are on the menu?
sikkerhet:Papa Johns has a spinach alfredo sauce thats delicious but only gets ordered maybe once a week, and it hits its sell-by date 3 days after you open the bag but no one actually throws it out until its either gone or nasty looking. Dominos has a gluten-free pizza crust and I dont know why they bother because if you actually have a gluten intolerance you shouldnt be ordering pizza.
Stay away from the Spinach Alfredo Sauce pizza? That wont be too hard for me.
Why Is Stuffed Crust So Good
Pizza Huts stuffed crust pizza doesnt add that many more calories. So when you add even more cheese by literally stuffing it into the crust, one might think your calorie count will go way up. Well, stuffed crust lovers rejoice! As it turns out, stuffed crust doesnt actually add that many more calories to your meal.
Also Check: Where To Buy Rao’s Sauce
Can I Use Butter Instead Of Margarine
Yes, you can definitely use butter instead of margarine for this recipe. Butter will give you a rich, delicious flavor.
If you decide to use butter I recommend using clarified butter. This helps prevent the butter from separating. Melt the butter on low in a saucepan. The milk solids will start to rise to the top. Remove the solids with a slotted spoon so that you are left with clear butter. Discard the solids and use only the clear butter for the recipe.
More About Papa Johns Pizza Cheese Dipping Sauce By Todd Wilbur Recipes
FORMER PAPA JOHNS MANAGER SHARES RECIPE FOR DIPPING SAUCE …
PAPA JOHNS PIZZA DOUGH RECIPE – COMPLETELY PIZZA
PAPA JOHN’S – TODD WILBUR’S TOP SECRET COPYCAT RESTAURANT …
COPYCAT PAPA JOHN’S PIZZA RECIPE – MY RECIPE MAGIC
COPYCAT PAPA JOHN’S PIZZA RECIPE – SIX SISTERS’ STUFF
COPYCAT PAPA JOHNS PIZZA RECIPE – RECIPES.NET
TOP SECRET RECIPES | PAPA JOHN’S DIPPING SAUCES
HOW TO MAKE PAPA JOHN’S GARLIC SAUCE AT HOME | EPICURIOUS
FromEstimated Reading Time
CHEESE PIZZA – PAPA JOHN’S GUAM
FromOffer CountAvailabilityPrice Range
COPYCATTING PAPA JOHN. RECIPE BY MARY – COOKEATSHARE
PAPA JOHNS GARLIC DIPPING SAUCE | PIZZA MAKING FORUM
PAPA JOHN& AMP #39 S PIZZA CHEESE DIPPING SAUCE BY TODD WILBUR …
PIZZA INGREDIENTS – PAPA JOHN’S PIZZA
PAPA JOHN’S PIZZA SAUCE | PIZZA MAKING FORUM
& QUOT PAPA JOHN’S PIZZA& QUOT CHEESE DIPPING SAUCE. COULDN’T REALLY …
PAPA JOHN’S GARLIC DIPPING SAUCE : TOPSECRETRECIPES – FOOD …
PAPA JOHN’S PIZZA SAUCE – PIZZA MAKING, PIZZA RECIPES, AND …
PAPA JOHN’S MENU PRICES | ALL MENU PRICE
PIZZA INGREDIENTS – SIGNATURE EXTRAS – PAPA JOHN’S PIZZA
PAPA JOHNS GARLIC DIPPING SAUCE – OFF-TOPIC FOODS – PIZZA …
PAPA JOHNS GARLIC DIPPING SAUCE RECIPE 395
PAPA JOHN’S PIZZA CHEESE DIPPING SAUCE BY TODD WILBUR …
RECIPE: PAPA JOHNS DOUBLE CHEESEBURGER PIZZA AND BURGER …
Read Also: Texas Pete Hot Sauce Recipe
What Is Papa Johns 3 Cheese Blend
The Three Cheese Blend is made up of Provolone, Fontina, and Asiago cheeses, as stated on the companys website and while thats nice to know, its not a lot of information.Mar 14, 2020
What are the four flavors of Papa Johns papadias?, The four varieties are Italian, Philly Cheesesteak, Grilled BBQ Chicken& Bacon and Meatball Pepperoni and they come with a dipping sauce and pepperoncini pepper.
Furthermore, Whats in Papa Johns papadias?, Nutritional Information
Flatbread-style sandwich with Alfredo sauce, cheese, Italian sausage, salami and banana peppers. Served with pizza dipping sauce.
Finally, What is Papa Johns cheese sauce?, Cheese Sauce
1/2 cup milk. 2 teaspoons cornstarch. 1/4 cup Cheez Whiz. 2 teaspoon juice from canned jalapenos
Great Deals That Never Let You Down
We believe great food is a regular part of any life well-lived, so we’re always putting together new weekly deals for dedicated pizza lovers to enjoy. Join our email list and be the first to see Papa John’s menu items the minute they’re added to the mix, enjoy pizza deals, and take advantage of amazing savings you won’t want to miss. At Papa John’s, there’s always something delicious coming out of the oven, and we’re dedicated to giving you your share at great prices that won’t break the bank. Explore the possibilities today!
Read Also: World’s Strongest Hot Sauce
Make Sure To Pin The Recipe Or Repin It
Everyday at 1 pm PST/ 4pm EST Budget Savvy Diva posts a NEW RECIPE I might miss this time every now or then but I know you understand
Make sure to follow Budget Savvy Diva on Facebook
Find Copy Cat Restaurant Recipes HERE
Find Crock Pot Recipes HERE
Find Gluten Free Recipes HERE
Find more Recipes HERE
1/4 Cup Margarine
1 tsp Garlic Powder
Pinch of Salt
What To Do
Melt Margarine in the microwave
Add salt and powder
- ¼ Cup Margarine
- 1 tsp Garlic Powder
- Pinch of Salt
Copycat Papa John’s Garlic Sauce Recipe
It’s entirely possible that Papa John’s Pizza rose to fame in large part due to the brand’s buttery, garlicky dipping sauce. This simple sauce is the type of indulgent extra side that makes people actually want to eat their pizza crusts , rather than throwing them away. So whether you’re the type to douse your entire slice of pizza in Papa John’s garlic sauce, or you prefer to save the sauce for dipping your crusts, chances are you can’t make it through a box of pizza without breaking open the provided containers.
But guess what? You don’t have to order a whole pizza when you want some of that sauce. This Papa John’s garlic sauce copycat recipe developed by registered dietitian Kristen Carli is quick and easy to make at home, can be doubled or tripled in size if you’re prepping for a crowd , and frankly, is downright delicious.
Read Also: Texas Pete Hot Sauce Recipe
Add Seasonings Mix And Serve This Papa John’s Garlic Sauce Copycat Recipe
When the butter is melted, pour it into a small serving bowl and add the salt, garlic powder, and onion powder to the butter and whisk. You want the seasonings to combine completely with the butter to give the sauce that perfect, Papa John’s flavor with a nice, smooth texture. Serve the sauce while it’s still warm for the best possible flavor.
And keep in mind, just because this sauce is made for pizza doesn’t mean you can’t use it in different ways. Carli suggests using it over pasta with Parmesan cheese, as a bread dip, or brushed on toast before making a grilled cheese sandwich . You can even amp up the heat by adding a dash of red chili flakes to the sauce.
Can You Bake Two Pizzas At Once
Cook two pizzas at once if youre feeding a crowd. Place each pizza on a separate baking sheet. Put one baking sheet on the first oven rack and the other baking sheet on the second oven rack, as arranged before you preheated your oven. Allow the pizzas to cook for 23 to 27 minutes ovens vary in temperature.
Also Check: Texas Pete Hot Wing Sauce Recipe
Melt The Butter For This Papa John’s Garlic Sauce Copycat Recipe
Once your ingredients for this Papa John’s garlic sauce copycat recipe are ready to go, simply place the butter in a small saucepan and heat to medium heat, allowing the butter to melt completely. It’s a good idea to stir the butter as it melts to prevent it from getting too hot. Butter has a low smoke point, and it can burn if you’re not careful. When in doubt, turn the heat level down to prevent this from happening.
What To Serve With This Garlic Sauce
This sauce is great for dipping pizza, breadsticks, or even using it to spread on garlic bread. You could also use it for:
- Steak Drizzle on top of your cooked steak for a punch of flavor.
- Potatoes Try mixing it into mashed potatoes for the best garlic mashed potatoes.
- Pasta Toss with your favorite cooked pasta for an easy meal.
- Vegetables Top roasted vegetables with a little drizzle of this sauce.
- Seafood This sauce is perfect for thing like crab cakes, shrimp and fish.
Read Also: Texas Pete Hot Sauce Recipe
Portable Deliciousness For Any Occasion
A Papa John’s Papadia isn’t just any flatbread sandwich. It’s a hot, beautifully balanced meal that’s everything you do love about a hot, flatbread-style sandwich, but taken to the next level with generous portions of all your favorite Papa John’s ingredients and flavors. Think real cheese melted to perfection, juicy meats, and mountains of colorful veggies, all nestled snugly into fresh-baked flatbread made from Papa John’s own signature dough. Each Papadia features its own flavor profile and comes served alongside the ideal Papa John’s dipping sauce for a perfect series of bites from the first to the last. Choose from:
Together or separately, the above options make ideal finishing touches to any pizza order for a party, a family dinner, or even just a low-key Saturday night at home, as well as great ways to dress up an otherwise humdrum lunch hour!
The Papa John’s Dipping Sauce That Has Everyone Talking
Some things in life are practically loved by everyone. Arguably some contenders high on the universally-loved-list are pizza, novelty, and dipping sauce. So then it totally makes sense that nobody can keep their mouths shut about the new item from Papa John’s.
Last year on National Garlic Day yes there’s a day dedicated solely to the stuff vampires hate Papa John’s offered a Spicy Garlic Dipping Sauce, but the catch was, it was only available that day. Apparently everyone loved it a ton because it’s back now, and probably forever. Rejoice, because you can stop rationing the stockpile of the sauce you collected last year that lives in the back of your silverware drawer .
The sauce is similar to Papa John’s long-loved Garlic Dipping sauce, but this new spicy version is packed with jalapenos and red chilies, enough to make you sweat at least if you’re a spice newb. Reviewers have said it’s a more generic heat, totally tolerable for even a spice-sensitive consumer. The fact that it’s not totally overpowering makes it versatile and good for all your pizza and breadstick needs .
Don’t Miss: Texas Pete Hot Sauce Recipe
How Dipping Sauce For Pizza Became Oddly Necessary
It was just a short time ago that dipping pizza in ranch was the Great Debate, with many claiming that the act was an abomination to pies everywhere. Now, the ranch-pizza combo is an integral part of the pizza experience its even found on the menus of many sophisticated restaurants.
But its important to ask how something that elicits such an emotional response from diners became a mainstream option so much so that before you hit the place order button in your delivery pizza app, youre probably adding a couple cups of dipping sauce to the list. Americas four largest pizza chains Papa Johns, Pizza Hut, Little Caesars, and Dominos all offer ranch along with a variety of dips on their menus, tiny upsells that contribute to the $45.15 billion in pizza restaurant sales in 2016. But how did we get here?
It Starts With Breadsticks
According to Saint Josephs University professor of food marketing John Stanton, asking Which came first, consumer demand or restaurant upsell? is like saying Which came first, the chicken or the egg? Its impossible to know, but in food marketing, products tend to become popular because of both consumer demand and restaurants looking to increase profits. All companies are always looking for something new, a different edge, Stanton says. If becomes something that people will pay for and expect, eventually youll see it in more places.