Substitute Soy Sauce For Coconut Aminos

Must Try

How Is Tamari Made

Soy Sauce Substitutes: What is Coconut Aminos?

Tamari follows a similar path of production as soy sauce, though there are some marked differences. The largest difference is that tamari is the byproduct of miso paste and no wheat is used during the sauces production. Lets outline the exact process that San-J follows when making their tamari.

  • First, soybeans are soaked in water before being cooked in a steam cooker.
  • These beans are then shaped into nuggets and dusted with aspergillus oryzae. Aspergillus oryzae is more commonly known as Koji in English. Koji is a type of mold that has been embraced by East Asian cuisine.
  • The coated soybeans are then placed into an incubation chamber where temperature and humidity are carefully calculated. With high heat and high moisture levels, the Koji we mentioned above assists in developing a mold that covers the entire pan of soybeans.
  • Over a two day span, the nuggets form a yellow mold.
  • Now, the soybeans are transferred to a fermentation tank where salt and water is then added. This mixture is known as moromi.
  • The moromi is then aged for up to six months.
  • After aging, the moromi is pressed through a cloth, thus yielding raw tamari. This tamari is then pasteurized and filtered.
  • Recipes With Coconut Aminos

    Feel free to substitute coconut aminos in any recipe calling for soy sauce, though be aware that you won’t get the exact same flavor and you may need to adjust the salt to compensate for the lower sodium content in the coconut aminos. If a recipe calls for a portion of both light and dark soy sauces, you can acceptably substitute an equal amount of coconut aminos for both, but you won’t get the same depth of flavor in the finished dish.

    Can You Use Vinegar Instead Of Soy Sauce

    Soy sauce has quite a unique taste to it, at once salty, tart, sweet, and meaty. But unfortunately there are very few recipe ingredients that can mimic the taste of soy sauce exactly.

    There are plenty of people out there however, who have allergies to soybean and soy products but dont want to miss out on their much loved soy sauce based recipes. And we have managed to source such a recipe for you. This recipe includes vinegar, but vinegar alone is just no substitute for soy sauce.

    To find the recipe, just scroll up a little further to the question Can I make my own soy sauce?.

    Read Also: Rao Pasta Sauce Where To Buy

    Healthy Soy Sauce Substitute Recipe

    It occurred to me, though, that we could borrow the best parts of a few ingredients to create a fab soy sauce substitute.

    • We use coconut aminos for the depth and flavor, but not too much, lest we end up with a sugary sauce!
    • Fish sauce provides a rich umami flavor and the saltiness we all love from soy sauce.

    But how do we get that fermented vegetable flavor and cut down on the intensity from the fish sauce? Are you ready?

    Coconut Aminos And Apple Cider Vinegar

    Coconut Secret Vinegar or Aminos both are great ...

    Like Braggs version, coconut aminos that contain apple cider vinegar can deliver benefits from the vinegar itself. Apple cider vinegar is an age-old ingredient with published research to back many of its health claims, particularly for improving blood sugar regulation. One older study, published in Diabetes Care, was conducted in men and women with type 2 diabetes. Researchers found that compared to water, consuming apple cider vinegar before bed with the same snack , led to lower blood sugar levels the following morning.

    Another study in the same journal assessed people with diabetes, as well as healthy adults, and those with pre-diabetic insulin resistance. When less than one ounce of apple cider vinegar was consumed with a high-carb meal , all three groups experienced better blood glucose outcomes compared to a placebo. In those with pre-diabetes, blood sugar values were nearly 50 percent lower, and they dropped by about 25 percent in those with diabetes.

    Read Also: Rao Spicy Sauce

    Risks And Side Effects

    As coconut aminos contain only two ingredients, theyre an extremely safe condiment to consume.

    There is no research to suggest overuse of coconut aminos leads to adverse effects. However, its possible to be allergic to coconut, although its quite rare.

    Signs of coconut allergies or food sensitivities include nausea and vomiting, rash, hives and diarrhea.

    Not a health side effect, but one note to consider when looking into coconut aminos is its price point. It is a bit more expensive than soy sauce, costing about 50 percent more. However, when you cook with this healthier option, youll know that you arent consuming GMO ingredients, excessive sodium and other scary additives.

    What Is The History Of Soy Sauce

    Soy sauce dates back to 206 B.C. in China. This was during the Western Han dynasty and was used as a way to bulk out the salt stocks to save money.

    It is believed it originated from a substance known as chiang or jiang. Archaeologists found written records of soy sauce on bamboo at the archeological site of Mawangdui.

    Once it began to gain popularity in China, replications popped up in Korea, Indonesia, Japan, and across Southeast Asia.

    In the 1600s, it became popular in Europe due to trading between Japan and the Netherlands.

    You May Like: Kraft Sweet And Sour Sauce Recipes

    Coconut Secret Coconut Aminos Sauce

    A popular soy-free, gluten-free, and vegan soy sauce alternative is coconut aminos sauce, made by Coconut Secret. This sauce comes from the sap of coconut trees and is made with Gran Molucas sea salt, cultivated in the Philippines.

    It contains just 90 milligrams of sodium per serving, which is far less than soy sauce and some other alternatives. The sauce also contains 17 amino acids, giving it health benefits beyond those of soy sauce.

    Drawbacks to coconut aminos are the cost and availability. Some people also notice a sweeter flavor and aftertaste when compared to soy sauce.

    Soy Sauce Substitutes That Are Homemade

    Substitution Series: Coconut Aminos for Soy Sauce

    For crowds that are DIYers, there are a number of different recipes for substitutes for soy sauce. Generally speaking, these soy substitutes will not include any sources of gluten, wheat, or soy. Similar to coconut Aminos, this will be an ideal option for those trying to avoid certain allergy-causing ingredients. Recipes may vary but these homemade concoctions will commonly include molasses, sugar, or honey. This should be considered by individuals who are trying to manage the levels of their blood sugar. While coconut Aminos are developed using substances that are sugary, it has reduced the content of sugar because of the process of fermentation. In fact, it only has a gram of sugar for every 5 ml or per teaspoon which will have little to no significant impact on the blood sugar levels of individuals

    Recommended Reading: Costco Rao Sauce

    Why Would You Need A Soy Sauce Substitute

    There are several reasons why you might need to replace soy sauce in your diet. It’s such a common condiment that many people refrigerate soy sauce alongside their ketchup and mustard without giving it a second thought, but as the main ingredient in soy sauce is of course soy, that can become a problem. Among children, 0.4% have a soy allergy, and though some may outgrow it, some of them do not. Many soy sauces also contain wheat, so those with gluten sensitivity or celiac’s disease must avoid them as well.

    Apart from the allergen concern with soy sauce, there is also about 879 milligrams of sodium per 1 tablespoon of soy sauce. Too much sodium can impact your kidneys and your blood pressure, leading to cardiovascular issues like stiffening arteries, high blood pressure, heart attack, and stroke. Finding a low-sodium soy sauce substitute could be a great boon to your overall health, and may be vital for those who already have high blood pressure.

    Maggi Asian Seasoning Sauce

    This sauce may contain soy, most certainly contains wheat, and has about 1850 milligrams of sodium per tablespoon. Why is it on this list? Well, it’s still a flavor alternative to soy sauce that can be used in much the same way in Asian dishes and as a marinade, though it won’t serve as an alternative in the areas of food allergies or sodium content.

    You May Like: Rao’s Homemade Sauce

    How To Make My Soy Sauce Alternative Recipe

    Making a homemade sub for soy sauce is way easier than you may think! Just be sure to have a clean jar or bottle for storage before beginning.

    • Add all of your ingredients to a saucepan, leaving out the salt and sesame oil for now.
    • Bring it to a boil and then let it simmer on medium heat for 10 minutes.
    • Turn off the heat, add the salt and sesame oil , and stir until its mixed well.
    • Let your soy sauce cool, then place it in an airtight container and store it for up to a week. You can even freeze it for later use.

    Fish And Oyster Sauce

    Coconut Aminos... Substitute for light soy sauce.

    Fish and oyster sauces are often used to replace soy sauce in recipes, though for different reasons.

    Oyster sauce is a thick, rich sauce made from boiled oysters. Its more akin to dark soy sauce, though notably less sweet. Its usually chosen as a dark soy sauce alternative due to its thick texture and culinary application, not for any particular health benefit.

    Coconut aminos would not make a good substitute for dark soy sauce, as its too thin and light.

    Fish sauce is a thinner, lighter and salty seasoning sauce made from dried fish. Its typically used in Thai-style dishes and is both gluten- and soy-free.

    Fish sauce is high in sodium, so its not a viable soy sauce replacement for those trying to reduce their salt intake .

    Moreover, fish and oyster sauces would not be appropriate substitutions for vegetarian or vegan diets.


    Coconut aminos is lower in sodium than most other popular soy sauce alternatives while also being free from common allergens. It may not be as useful for some culinary dishes.

    You May Like: Is Raos Keto

    How Is Soy Sauce Made

    Traditionally, soy sauce is made by soaking and steaming soybeans. Then, roasted wheat flour and fungal spores are combined with the cooked soybean mixture. After these ingredients, brine is added, and the mix is left to ferment. Finally, the entire solution is filtered, heated to kill any fungus or bacteria, and packaged.

    There are several variations of soy sauce primarily distinguished by brewing technique and soy to wheat ratio. Tamari sauce, which is most similar to liquid aminos, contains the least wheat and is very dark. White soy sauces use the most wheat. Less traditional, mass-produced soy sauce may use an acid solution to process the soybeans instead of the conventional cooking and soaking.

    Coconut Aminos: Is It The Perfect Soy Sauce Substitute

    Soy sauce is a popular condiment and seasoning sauce, especially in Chinese and Japanese cuisine, but it may not be suitable for all diet plans.

    If youre adjusting your diet to reduce salt, avoid gluten or eliminate soy, coconut aminos may be a good alternative.

    This article takes a look at what the science says about this increasingly popular soy sauce substitute and explains why it may be a healthier option.

    Read Also: Rao’s Costco

    Tamari Vs Soy Sauce Vs Coconut Aminos

    by Lisa Bryandisclosure policy

    Tamari is a great gluten-free soy sauce alternative. But what is tamari? And how does it differ from soy sauce and coconut aminos in terms of production and flavor. Is all tamari gluten-free? Lets dive in and Ill explain.

    When I went gluten-free several years ago, I still remember being shocked at how gluten managed to sneak into so many unsuspecting foods. Soups, teas, chewing gum.and sushi? Say what?

    As an avid sushi-lover, it broke my heart to learn that gluten was indeed in my soy sauce. And in fact, theres quite a bit of it. But after a little online sleuthing I soon discovered tamari and coconut aminos my sushi saviors and go-tos for Asian-inspired meals.

    But as these food products were new to me , lets break down how theyre different, starting with the one youre likely most familiar with.

    The Rise Of Coconut Aminos

    WHAT IS COCONUT AMINOS ? Soy-sauce substitute, what it tastes like, and coconut aminos recipes !

    If you follow healthy recipe accounts online, youve probably noticed one trendy ingredient pop up oftencoconut aminos. This liquid ingredient is often used as a substitute for soy saucepopular in Asian cuisine, specifically Chinese and Japanese. Coconut aminos shares similar culinary properties with its traditional counterpart, but its quite different in its composition.

    Heres a look at what coconut aminos is made from, and some of the reasons why its become so standard, particularly in health-focused cooking. Plus, find out if its actually healthier than soy sauce.

    Also Check: Texas Pete Sauce Recipe

    What Are The Health Benefits Of Coconut Aminos

    “Coconut aminos are a great allergy-friendly soy sauce substitute,” says Amer. “It’s also lower sodium, which is beneficial for salt-sensitive individuals.”

    What dietary boxes do liquid aminos check off?

    • soy-free
    • Whole30-friendly
    • Keto-friendly

    As for specific health benefits, coconut aminos has been noted for its amino acid content, which are the building blocks for protein, and that it possibly lowers the risk of heart disease, diabetes, and colon cancer. However, there are zero studies that exist to back up anything.

    “There are some health claims attributed to coconut aminos however, we need more research to confirm these,” says Vandana Sheth, RDN, CDE, FAND, Los Angeles-based registered dietitian nutritionist and author of My Indian Table: Quick & Tasty Vegetarian Recipes.

    And when it comes to any negatives, if you have a coconut allergy, you should skip coconut aminos. And if you’re watching your sodium intake, you should also be cautious.

    “Just because it is lower in sodium does not mean that it is salt-free. Monitoring your portions will help keep the sodium content appropriate,” says Sheth.

    What Is Coconut Aminos

    Coconut aminos is a popular soy sauce alternative. Its wheat, gluten, and soy-free, and also Whole30 approved and paleo-, keto-, and vegan-friendly. It contains no MSG and is low-glycemic. For all these reasons, coconut aminos is an excellent seasoning for those who have soy, wheat, or gluten allergies, food sensitivities or follow an alternative diet.Coconut aminos is considered a healthier alternative to traditional soy sauce because its lower in sodium, containing only 90 milligrams per teaspoon. In comparison, regular soy sauce has 280 milligrams of sodium per teaspoon.For these reasons, coconut aminos has become popular for healthifying all kinds of savory Asian food recipes. You can use coconut aminos as a stir-fry sauce, marinade, in salad dressings, and for making the flavors pop in veggies or fish coconut milk curries and cauliflower rice. Its even delicious as a dipping sauce for takeout sushi.

    While coconut aminos is a great condiment to keep on hand, its not always easy to find at the grocery store. Or you may have to wait a few days and order it on Amazon. If youre in a pickle, lets see what else you can use as a coconut aminos substitute while keeping the integrity of flavors in your dish.

    There are a few brands on the market. My go-to brand is Coconut Secret.

    Recommended Reading: Costco Rao’s

    What Are Coconut Aminos Exactly

    Traditional soy sauce is made by fermenting a mixture of soybeans and roasted wheat in salt and water, and straining out the solids so that only a liquid remains.

    Coconut aminos are made through a similar process. However, instead of soybeans and wheat, it’s made by mixing coconut palm sap with salt and water, according to culinary scientist Jessica Gavin.

    As a result, coconut aminos are sweeter and less salty than typical extremely-salty soy sauce. However, the savory flavor is similar enough that coconut aminos can be used similarly to soy sauces in stir-fries, marinades, dipping sauces, vinaigrettes, and more, Gavin says.

    Can You Substitute Worcestershire Sauce For Coconut Aminos


    30. Coconut aminos. In the same way that soy sauce is, coconut aminos are a good substitute for Worcestershire in equal measure as the original condimentand by using them, you can better control the added salt in your finished dish. This substitute is great just about anywhere you need to use Worcestershire.

    Also Check: Texas Pete Recipes

    Homemade Soy Sauce Substitutes

    For the do-it-yourself crowd, theres a wide selection of possible recipes for homemade soy sauce substitutes.

    Typically, homemade soy sauce substitutes eliminate sources of soy, wheat and gluten. Like coconut aminos, they may be a good choice for those avoiding these allergens.

    Though recipes vary, homemade sauces usually add sugar from molasses or honey. This may be a problem for those looking to manage their blood sugar.

    Even though coconut aminos is made from a sugary substance, it has a low sugar content due to its fermentation process. It contains just one gram of sugar per teaspoon , which is unlikely to have any significant impact on your blood sugar.

    Many homemade recipes use high-sodium ingredients, such as broth, bouillon or table salt. Depending on the amounts used, these may be less suitable than coconut aminos for those looking to reduce sodium in their diets.

    Can I Make My Own Soy Sauce

    Earlier in this article we provided you with a recipe for a vegan homemade soy sauce. But, here it is again, to save you from having to scroll through:


    • Salt


    Add all of the ingredients except the fenugreek seeds and salt to a saucepan. Place over a medium heat and whisk until it reaches boiling point.

    When it boils, reduce the heat and add in the fenugreek seeds. Simmer the mixture until it has reduced by half. This should strongly resemble soy sauce.

    At this point, you should taste a little and decide whether to add salt or not.

    Pass the liquid through a sieve or strainer to remove any lumps. Allow it to cool and then transfer it to a sterilized glass jar.

    To note – this recipe will make about half a cup or 125 ml of soy sauce concentrate.

    Also Check: Classico Roasted Garlic Alfredo Pasta Sauce

    Popular Recipes

    More Recipes Like This