Best Store Bought Spaghetti Sauce

Must Try

What Other Kind Of Meat Can You Add To Spaghetti Sauce

An Italian Reviews Pasta Sauce | Blind Tomato Sauce Taste Test
  • Ground beef
  • Ground turkey
  • Italian sausage

Once your meat and veggies are seasoned and cooked, you can add the jar of your favorite sauce, tomato paste, the canned tomatoes and remaining seasonings. The sauce then gets simmered for 20 minutes and then you can toss in a handful of parmesan cheese for even more yumminess!

Cucina Antica Tomato Basil

Ingredients: Imported Italian San Marzano Tomatoes, Tomatoes , Onions, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Salt, Basil, White Pepper, Black Pepper

Appearance & Consistency: As contradictory as it seems, Cucina Antica somehow managed to make a sauce that’s simultaneously chunky and runny.

Taste: Tough the basil shreds were visible to the eye, they were undetectable to the taste buds. Unfortunately, this sauce was lacking the authentic flavor its packaging foreshadowed.

Eat This, Not That! Verdict:

Considering the rustic labeling and Italian name that translates to “antique kitchen,” I expected this sauce to boast more pronounced Mediterranean flavors. Rather than getting a refreshing whiff of tomato and basil, my nostrils were hit with an unpalatable dish detergent scent. My colleague also affirmed that the taste is almost Windex-like. What in the world? To say the least, I was confused.

Another Brooklynite Victoria Has Been Producing Red Sauce Since 1929

Victoria uses a 90-minute kettle-cooking process a direct challenge to mainstream manufacturers that use heat-transfer tubes to flash cook their sauces that results in a beautiful texture of whole tomatoes broken down in their own juices until irregularly lumpy.

Without puree, the base was a little on the waterier side, but the coarse tomatoes were plentiful enough that it wasn’t runny.

As with the sauce from Carbone and Rao’s, I could see some oil floating, but I more noticed the diced onions, tomato seeds, and smaller pieces of basil, which were dark and fine.

It tasted clean and fresh, sweet at first, then suddenly sharp before it tapered off into sweet again a lovely ride.

Unfortunately, this journey ended early when the sauce was served warm. The flavor considerably lightened up and became fleeting and shallow.

The basil remained detectable, distributing well and evenly across the pasta in its tiny pieces, but the tomato lost a lot of its freshness.

It just wasn’t very assertive, even though the water didn’t separate as much as expected. Not devoid of personality but in need of a partner, this would pair well with high-quality or fresh pasta.

Recommended Reading: Freddy’s Sauce For Sale

Mezzetta Napa Valley Homemade Marinara

Moving on to store-bought marinara sauces that look a little nicer, we have Mezzetta Napa Valley Homemade Sauce. The sauce comes in a good-looking jar with a fancy label, winning points for looks, while even the name of the brand evokes an Italian essence. But that doesn’t mean the sauce is good. In fact, it’s bland, overly salty, and feels like a rip-off, considering the higher price.

One review of the pasta sauce was precise in its criticism, calling Mezzetta’s stuff “flavorless.” Another described it as downright “horrible,” while quite a few complained about the overwhelming salt content of this jarred marinara sauce. So basically, not only will the Mezzetta Napa Valley Homemade Sauce have a pretty poor flavor, but it will also likely be way too salty for your palate, seriously letting you down. So, next time you’re grocery shopping, just skip this purchase.

Tastes Like Your Grandma Made It: Lidias Marinara Sauce

10 Best Store

OK, our grandma was a native New Yorker who didnt know how to boil water, but someones grandma probably makes a sauce just like this. Celebrity chef Lidia Bastianich has bottled her famous sauce recipe, and she doesnt skimp on the high-quality ingredients . But warning: Its a little garlicky, so you might want to chew some gum afterward.

Read Also: Hot Sauce Jars For Canning

Aldi Specially Selected Premium Marinara

In terms of money-saving groceries, Aldi is a pretty great store to shop at. Nothing is too expensive, and there are a ton of options. The store brand of marinara sauce there, too, is pretty impressive. Aldi’s Specially Selected Premium Marinara isn’t the absolute best premade sauce on the market, to be fair, but it might just surprise you anyway.

According to one review of Aldi’s sauce, it’s decent overall, though “a little on the bland side.” But there’s also a bit of a culinary conspiracy theory that says the Aldi sauce is actually the same as Rao’s Marinara sauce, meaning you’d be getting an especially good deal on an amazing store-bought sauce if you buy the Aldi brand. Whether or not the two sauces are the same, it’s hard to deny that the Aldi’s sauce is a lot better than you might have thought.

The Silver Palate Low Sodium Marinara

Ingredients: Imported San Marzano Whole Peeled Tomatoes, California Whole Peeled and Crushed Tomatoes, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Fresh Onions, Fresh Carrots, Fresh Garlic, Pear Concentrate, Spices

Appearance & Consistency: Though the general consistency was light, albeit with sporadic tomato lumps, this sauce was jam-packed with spices by the looks of it. Not to mention, the fresh carrots added some crunchiness, which I can predict will work well in a slew of recipes.

Taste: Despite being the lowest in sodium of all our test panelists, The Silver Palate didn’t disappoint my taste buds. Sure, it wasn’t as umami-packed as some of the other picks, but it did boast unexpected fresh flavors and hearty spices.

Eat This, Not That! Verdict:

This pick is lacking sodium, but that doesn’t mean it’s not rife with flavor. Instead of relying on the heart-harming stuff, The Silver Palate’s marinara takes advantage of quality ingredients, such as imported San Marzano tomatoes and EVOO, to lend the sauce its complexity. This surprisingly delicious sauce proves that you can keep the salt off your fork without compromising flavor.

Read Also: How Do You Make Mcdonald’s Big Mac Sauce

Why Trust The Spruce Eats

The Spruce Eats writer Alyssa Langer is a registered dietitian and foodie, always curious about the next food or ingredient craze and hungry to learn, and try more. Having worked in cookbook publishing, CPG label data, nutrition writing, and meal kits, her diverse background and varied interests provide a unique perspective that fosters clear, well-researched and trustworthy reviews.

How We Chose Our Products

Prego vs Francesco Rinaldi Marinara Sauce – FoodFights Best Canned Marinara Pasta Sauce Review

To choose the 10 best store-bought pasta sauces, we chose by evaluating the following criteria:

  • What sauce goes best with what pasta
  • How nutritious the sauce is
  • The type of packaging and how convenient it is

You’ll want to keep these features in mind when searching for your perfect sauce! Check out our buying guide for more in-depth tips on how to choose, too.

Also Check: Recipes Using Bertolli Creamy Basil Alfredo Sauce

Best Traditionally Made Option Mezzetta Basil Pesto Sauce

If you can get your hands on anything that has been made using the traditional methods and ingredients of its origin, then you can get your hands on something special.

This is especially true when it comes to food and sauces. This Mezzetta Basil Pesto Sauce is exactly that and so much more. Made using a classic Italian recipe and some of the best, high-quality ingredients, this pesto sauce has tantalizing flavors.

As soon as it hits your mouth, you will pick up hints of pine nuts, garlic, Extra Virgin Oil, fresh basil, and savory Parmesan cheese.

Coming to you in an easy to use glass jar, this sauce can be used on a wide variety of dishes, including grilled meats, roasted vegetables, pasta, fish, and so much more.


  • Pairs well with a lot of dishes


  • Taste might be too mild for some people

What To Make With Spaghetti Sauce

When it comes to a jar of pasta sauce, the options are vast. Want a quick dinner? Just stir in your favorite pasta and add a sprinkle of cheese. Want something a bit more substantial? Use it in baked ziti or manicotti. Marinara is for more than just spaghetti after all! Just check out all these amazing takes.

Don’t Miss: Panda Express Sweet Chili Sauce

Second Runner Up: Classico

Many of us on the team grew up with Classico, so it felt familiar and homey. The flavor doesn’t knock it out of the park — you likely won’t be taking secret spoonfuls straight from the jar like we were with Rao’s. But it has a comforting flavor, and is a solid choice to keep on hand in the pantry for quick, versatile meals.

While we all felt it was a good enough weeknight contender, Carrie found it a bit too sweet and Summer found the flavor unbalanced. Claudia had qualms with the texture, finding it a little soupy with very little coatability.

Emma, on the other hand, loved the chunky texture, as did I — it straddles that tough to achieve texture zone of perfectly chunky but still uniform enough to incorporate into your noodles. Emma put it best: This was my backup favorite to Raos, my Tuesday night ‘need a meal’ sauce.” And I’m going to go out on a limb and guess that many of us have had Tuesday night ‘need a meal’ situations.

Megan Gordon

The Official Pasta Sauce Power Rankings

Best store bought spaghetti sauce recipe,
  • Copy Link URLCopied!
  • Print

Lets get to it, shall we? I present the indisputable and 1,000% correct Pasta Sauce Power Rankings. The general rules are:

I got jarred sauce , bought standard marinara or the closest approximation I could find and tried to include no more than one jar per brand. There are a lot of sauces here and, just as when looking at a list of Chumbawamba members, it can become overwhelming and difficult to tell them apart. You wont really go wrong with, say, the top dozen or so sauces on this list.

I ranked these by taste and attractiveness of packaging lets face it, when youre looking for a new pasta sauce, its usually the simple/earnestly rustic label that gets your attention.

Cost is difficult to pin down and, given theres a wide variety of prices you might pay depending on the retailer, I didnt use it as a metric. That said, when something is a particularly good value, I note that in the ranking.

1. Raos Marinara

This is a little complicated, so bear with me. In December, I tweeted out a photo of Victoria marinara sauce and declared it the best on the market. That was incorrect, and we regret the error. However.

Victoria does make the best sauce, but its the premium White Linen brand, typically found at Costco, thats superior, not the standard marinara . So: Why not just put Victoria White Linen at the top of the ranking?

Packaging Attractiveness Rating: 12

2. Mezzetta Marinara

Packaging Attractiveness Rating: 25

Read Also: All Clad Stainless 3 Qt Sauce Pan

Best Store Bought Pesto: Perfect For Quick Dishes

May 2, 2021 by Ligia Lugo

Many different types of foods are just an easy pick for the Americas Top Favorite Dinner list.

Of course, the foods on the list are subjective to the individual, but if you take a survey of the entire country, you will undoubtedly find pasta more often than not on that list. And what is pasta without a delicious sauce such as pesto to go with it?

For years now, Italian sauces such as Alfredo and marinara have dominated the most popular and delectable list.

Slowly, however, more and more people are starting to realize that other, different, yet delicious options are available on the market. Out of all the other sauces, pesto has garnered the most interest from foodies.

Its just one of those highly versatile sauces. You can use it as a sauce to slather over your noodles or something to finish off your sandwiches. Ideally, however, its the kind of sauce you want on your pasta.

Williams Sonoma Truffle Alfredo Pasta Sauce

Ah, truffles. There may have never been and will never be such an overhyped, often misunderstood fungus. While shaving fresh, $100 by the ounce, truffles over your at-home pasta dish is going to cost you a pretty penne , we’ve found an affordable way to indulge in this fungi’s flavor without fainting from the price tag. Williams Sonoma may be synonymous for overpriced kitchen appliances and stuff you don’t need, but they do offer a nice selection of ready-made cooking sauces, baking mixes, and other pantry essentials.

Williams Sonoma Truffle Alfredo Pasta Sauce is a Northern Italian spin on classic Alfredo, featuring the flavor of white truffles. This sauce is infused with truffle oil , not actual truffles, but we don’t mind it one bit. It may even rival some of the froufrou fancy dishes of truffle pasta that you would find in an upscale restaurant. This stuff is seriously delicious and the possibilities for what you can do with it are endless. We love a simple angel hair pasta and grilled chicken or a butternut squash ravioli in the winter months. You may even be inclined to eat it by the spoonful. Don’t worry, we won’t judge you.

Recommended Reading: Muir Glen Organic Tomato Sauce

Trader Joe’s Organic Marinara Sauce

Trader Joe’s knows no end when it comes to their crowd-pleasing products. They are continually wowing us with their new additions as well as tried and true long-time favorites. On any given pilgrimage, we’ve been known to pick up a bottle of Two Buck Chuck and some cauliflower gnocchi. With over 500 locations spread across over 40 states, the low-price grocery giant’s success story may be partly due to their fantastic selection of store brand items.

Cleverly named “Trader Giotto’s,” their Italian centric products offer everything from whole milk fresh mozzarella to organic brown rice penne pasta. While the standard jar of sauce will set you back or even exceed your total daily sodium intake as recommended by the American Heart Association, Trader Joe’s No Salt Added Organic Marinara Sauce features just a fraction of the amount of salt and as an added bonus, zero grams of fat. This is heavy on the pepper, as the flavorful vegetable contributes to the sweetness without the addition of sugar.

Barilla Traditional $350 24 Ounces

Prego Traditional vs Prego Marinara, FoodFights Reviews Which Italian Pasta Spaghetti Sauce is Best.

Though not as universally beloved by our team, Barilla’s Traditional sauce is a solid option for a weeknight dinner. It has a much stronger, zestier garlic taste than many of the others, and that certainly isn’t a bad thing. With a smoother texture than Classico, editors found themselves liking it the more they tasted, saying, “It has character.”

You May Like: Spaghetti Recipe With Ground Beef And Prego Sauce

Prego Farmers’ Market Classic Marinara Sauce

Price: $3.99Look, Im not one to be swayed by an obvious marketing ploy, especially one that aims to charm bring-your-own-grocery-bag types with a mason jar-style container, rustic brown paper label and distressed fake stencil lettering. But damn you, Prego, you wormed your way into my jaded heart. Overlook the exterior and youre in for a refreshingly simple ride that feels more like it came from an legit garden instead of an assembly line. Its all garlic right out the gate, followed by a rich blend of black pepper, tomato, basil, and oregano and summed up with a sweet-n-tangy kicker. The consistency is on the thicker side, not a great match for a slippery bowl of noodles, but I imagine it would be incredible in something that calls for a heartier spread, like lasagna or thick crust pizza.

Prego+ Plant Protein Italian Tomato Sauce With Roasted Garlic And Herb 24 Ounce Jar


  • THE DELICIOUS PREGO TASTE YOUR FAMILY KNOWS AND LOVES: The same delicious tomato sauce your family knows and loves, now packed with powerful proteins from vegetables.
  • LOADED WITH VEGGIES: With tomatoes as the number one ingredient, its no wonder each half cup serving delivers 40% of your daily vegetables. Each 1/2 cup serving of sauce provides 1 cup equivalent of vegetables.
  • FLAVORFUL TOMATO SAUCE: Made with sweet, vine-ripened tomatoes that are blended with roasted garlic and herbs for a savory taste that is authentically Italian
  • QUICK & EASY DINNERS: Pour it over pasta, use it as a base for your own recipe, or add it to a family favorite.
  • FEED THE WHOLE FAMILY: One jar is 24 ounces, easily enough for a dinner for five.

You May Like: How To Make Shrimp Alfredo With Ragu Alfredo Sauce

In Addition To Being A Sauce Maker Carbone Is A Michelin

This restaurant’s 2013 opening has made quite a mark on the New York City food scene.

Between its old-school dining experience, exclusivity hook with reservations released only once a week, mega-powered ownership, and Michelin-starred cuisine, its success is strategic and so is itssauce’s formula.

At first glance, it was considerably darker than the other sauces a deep brick with scarlet oil splotches and visibly wilted fresh basil.

It was already sweet and rich when cold, and though it uses puree, whole tomatoes are listed first in the ingredients, which was evident in its chunky texture.

There was a lingering whole-mouth feel to the sauce, with a malty, mushroom-like sense and a reminder of cheese, even though none is used in the recipe.

It immediately struck me that this is the kind of sauce you’d want to put on a thick, breaded cutlet for chicken Parmesan.

This impression got stronger after it was warmed and mixed into the pasta, to which it clung well.

The maltiness opened up to be less mushroom-like and more reminiscent of caramelized onions. It was a flavor that was hard to place and difficult to define, but not unpleasant.

There was a little tartness at the end to counterbalance the earthiness for an overall satisfying bite that would be made better only with chicken and mozzarella.

Popular Recipes

More Recipes Like This