Where Is Pizza Sauce In Grocery Store

Must Try

Signature Select Pizza Sauce

Phantom Gourmet: The Best Supermarket Sauce For Your Pizza

Average Price:$1.79

The Sauce:

I will never forget this sauce. Its so offensively bad that it is now forever ingrained in my memories. I will never forget its funky taste and toe-jam smell. According to the label, the funk is coming via the inclusion of parmesan cheese. Its a nice idea, any pizza can be improved by a sprinkling of parmesan, but if youre making homemade pizza, youre better of grating it fresh from the block for more flavor and less funk.

Best Type Of Pizza To Use It On:

None, throw this in the trash.

The Bottom Line:

Dont be fooled by the inclusion of parmesan, it sounds like a good idea but tastes like Chuck E. Cheese smells.

Top 10 Best Grocery Store Pizza Sauce In 2022

It is quite a common phenomenon to be confused over which is the grocery store pizza sauce to buy. This dilemma arises due to the existence of various types of grocery store pizza sauces that are present in the market. To reduce your conundrum, we have prepared a comprehensive guide of how you may pick the best grocery store pizza sauces available in the market.


Making Pizza At Home After Testing 10 Brands Our Test Kitchen Found The Best Store

Taste of Home

Sure, everyone loves a good delivery pizza here and there, but making your own pizza at home is just way more satisfyingplus you can get the toppings just right.

To make your pizza nights really exceptional, you need quality ingredientsincluding mozzarella cheese, crust and sauce. Sauce from scratch is delicious, but you dont always have the time to stir up a batch of homemade . Thats when you reach for a jar or can of store-bought pizza sauce!

But do you know which sauce will really make your homemade pizzas good enough to rival your favorite pizza joint?

You May Like: Where Can I Buy Rao’s Sauce

Best Recommendations And Buying Guide For Your Grocery Store Pizza Sauce

Before you venture out to purchase your preferred grocery store pizza sauce, take into consideration some factors. These factors will ultimately help you decide which grocery store pizza sauce is the right fit for your requirements.

Use the internet to do your research about all the available grocery store pizza sauces in the market. This is helpful for both online and retail/ in-person purchases. If you are buying from an online marketplace, try to ascertain the most trustworthy online store. Usually, the online shops that have the highest following of masses are the best ones.

These shops not only provide reliable products but also give the buyers a lot of diversified products to choose from. Search for the different types of grocery store pizza sauce available in the online store and find ones to choose from.

Read the reviews of people on the online pages to understand the detailed and nuanced pros and cons that entail this particular grocery store pizza sauce. You can also understand through other peoples reviews whether a particular grocery store pizza sauce fits your needs.

Assessing products online before buying the desired products from retail shops is also a very common phenomenon.

While doing the crucial research on the grocery store pizza sauces available in the market, you might ask yourself a few questions that will help you reach your decision:

Trader Joes Trader Giottos Fat

Great Value Pizza Sauce, 14 oz

Average Retail Price$1.99

The Sauce:

I expected a bit more from Trader Joes, this sauce didnt taste bad, but the smell was overwhelming and cheap. Trader Joes also carries a freshly made refrigerated pizza sauce and I wanted that for this ranking, but my local Joes was sold out. Im going to go ahead and suggest you spring for the refrigerated stuff over the jarred just by process of elimination though because this stuff tastes incredibly cheap.

According to the ingredients list, this sauce is made primarily from water and tomato paste with corn starch as a thickener, sugar, salt, and some basil and garlic powder, none of which you can taste.

Best Application:

Good for a flatbread pizza. You know, the boring, less flavorful version of a pizza.

The Bottom Line:

Not worth the jar it comes in, scan the refrigerated aisle for Joes fresh pizza sauce instead.

You May Like: Mcdonalds Zesty Sauce

How Do I Make My Pizza Dough Less Runny

Adding flour will take the stickiness away. You should go slowly and add a little bit of flour at a time. Knead the dough thoroughly each time you add a little, and repeat this process until the dough is no longer sticking to your hands and the surface. If you have used too much water, this should fix the problem.

Best Organic Option: Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce

Taste of Home

If you prefer to eat organic, try Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce. This sauce was packed with robust tomato flavoralmost as if the sauce was reduced a bit to really amp up the taste of the produce. But tomato isnt the only flavor youll find inside this can. Testers noticed a great balance of garlic as well.

Muir Glens pizza sauce was thicker than most we tried, but this is in no way a drawback. Our Test Kitchen thought the thicker texture of this sauce made it ideal for spreading across a homemade crust.

Recommended Reading: Hot Ones Eye Of The Scorpion Scoville Units

The Ideal Frozen Pizza

An ideal frozen cheese pizza has a delicious, chewy crust, tangy, bright tomato sauce, and a satisfying amount of gooey cheese. It also has to be easy to prepare. Sure, you can dress up your frozen pizza with an array of custom toppings, but for this test, I wanted the cheese pizza to have enough flavor right out of the box.

Is Pizza And Pasta Sauce The Same

Best Store Bought Pizza Sauce Reviews of 2021 | Don Pepino, Contadina, Muir Glen & Others

The Difference Between Pizza and Pasta Sauce Pizza sauce is an uncooked tomato sauce, while pasta sauce is cooked. The best pizza sauce is simply puréed tomatoes that are seasoned simply with salt and pepper and maybe a couple of extras like garlic, oregano, or a splash of balsamic or red wine vinegar.

Read Also: Texas Pete Buffalo Wing Recipes

Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef Original

This award winning pizza sauce is all you need to make all your guests wonder if youre not, in fact, a true chef. With a smooth texture that spreads evenly and a herby flavor, it will give your pizzas a special flavor that is hard to forget.

Unlike most pizza sauces that are too sweet or too acid, Pastorelli managed to achieve the perfect balance with just a slight hint of spiciness. The strong tomato flavor will compliment any pizza topping, from peppers and mushrooms to sausages and olives.

If youre looking for a pizza sauce that can rival that made at home, then look no further than Pastorelli.

Wegmans Bake & Rise Four Cheese Pizza $4

The first thing youll notice when you pop this in the oven is how extraordinarily bread-y the crust is. Taking a bite was like diving into a huge breadstick. The blend of mozzarella, Parmesan, Romano, and asiago cheeses didnt overwhelm and the tomato sauce was unobtrusive. At 24 minutes, it was the longest cook time of any pizza I tried, so if youre in a huge rush to get dinner on the table, look elsewhere.

You May Like: Raos Sauces

What Seasonings To Use To Improve Store Bought Pizza Sauce

As thoroughly American as it is these days, pizza is still inspired by Italian food. Fittingly, then, Italian seasonings are your best bet for adding extra flavor to a jarred pizza sauce.Italian seasoning mixes are common at the grocery store, but if you want more control over what specifically is going into the sauce, then youll probably want to go with options like oregano, basil, thyme, and even sage or bay leaf.If you like your pizza with a little extra spice, red pepper flakes are an excellent choice, too.If youre using dried seasonings feel free to add them early in the simmering process. If youve indulged in some fresh herbs, though, youll want to throw them in right at the end.

Raos Homemade Pizza Sauce

Casa Visco, Italian Style Pizza Sauce, 16 Oz.

Average Retail Price$4.99

The Sauce

Not everyone has the time or the will to make their own sauce, we get that. So if you want the best of the best with the lowest amount of effort, youve got to get a jar of Raos. Im genuinely surprised at just how good this sauce is. If you told me you made it the morning youre serving it, Id believe it. Its packed with a robust, nuanced flavor that is so good Id even recommend it as a pasta sauce. Chunks of tomato can be seen in every spoonful of sauce, but its still easily spreadable. Of all the slices, this is the only one I ate fully, because I couldnt get enough of the sauce. I took that as a strong sign that this was the best.

Raos is made with Italian whole peeled tomatoes, cherry tomatoes, olive oil, the usual suspects of spices , and carrots, which is added that sweet earthy flavor I could taste on the backend. That extra ingredient really makes all the difference.

Best Application:

Use it on any pizza, as a substitute for marinara , or anything that calls for a tomato-based sauce.

The Bottom Line:

This is the best-jarred pizza sauce your money will buy. Perfect for anyone who doesnt want to squeeze some San Marzanos by hand.

Don’t Miss: Low Carb Sweet And Sour Sauce Recipe

Customers Also Viewed These Products

28 x 21.6 x 15.6 cm 6.48 Kilograms
Item Weight
5.0 out of 5 stars
Date First Available

Prego Pizza Sauce Pizzeria Style

Average Retail Price$2.69

The Sauce:

Pregos Pizza Sauce claims to be pizzeria-style and Im not sure what that means, but there is nothing noteworthy or interesting about this sauce for it to be designated any sort of style. It tastes like the lowest quality ingredients possible were used in the creation of this sauce and looking at the label confirms that. Prego didnt bother using crushed tomatoes, they just got some tomato puree and cut it with canola oil.

The fact that this is ranking higher than Trader Joes is just a testament to just how bad that sauce is because this is truly some bottom-barrel stuff we are dealing with here.

Best Application:

On a pizza for a kid. One you dont particularly like. Its almost like ketchup all tomato and nothing else.

The Bottom Line:

If youre about to make a pizza and all you have is Prego Pizza Sauce, you might be better off going no sauce. This isnt worth opening and eating, you might as well save it forever in the event the world ends and you need sustenance in our post-apocalyptic hell-scape.

Even then, I hear mud doesnt taste too bad.

Recommended Reading: Zabs Hot Sauce Amazon

Is Prego Sauce Good For Pizza

It can be challenging if you want to make a whole pizza, but it takes no time at all to boil some pasta. For this recipe, you will just cook up your favorite type of pasta, and enjoy it with Prego Pasta Sauce. You can also assemble your favorite pizza toppings.

The Most Convenientand Deliciousproducts To Top A Homemade Pizza

HEALTHY PIZZA | Cauliflower Crust Pizza | Grocery Shopping

We independently research, test, review, and recommend the bestproductslearn more about our process. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

Before you reach for the jar of marinara sauce in your cabinet on pizza night, theres something you should know: Pizza sauce and pasta sauce are not the same thing. Sure, theyre closeand interchangeable in a pinchbut there is an inherent difference. Pizza sauce is essentially an uncooked tomato sauce pasta sauce is typically low-simmered to develop a deeper flavor. The lack of precooking ensures pizza sauce has a bright, tomato-forward taste. That said, you don’t need to rely on garden-fresh tomatoes for a killer pizza sauce. Today, there are plenty of no-fuss store-bought options that taste just as good.

Here are the best of the best pizza sauces you can buy.

The sauce, which has a total of just five ingredientstomatoes, corn oil, salt, spices, and garlic powderis free from some of the extra ingredients you sometimes find in store-bought products, including preservatives, starches, artificial sugar, added color, gums, and citric acid. Plus, the product is made with corn oil, rather than olive oil.

Finally, the sauce is packaged in a fun, retro-looking can thats easier to store than big, bulky glass jars.

Also Check: Arby’s Sauce Walmart

Boboli Traditional Italian Pizza Sauce

Average Retail Price$3.99

The Sauce:

This was the biggest surprise of the blind taste test and reaffirms why we even bother with blind taste tests in the first place! Bobolis Traditional Italian Pizza Sauce comes packaged with every Boboli pre-made crust, I fully expected it to be the worst of the bunch, and then when I saw the sauce with its dark BBQ-esque color and powerful smell I was sure it was going to taste awful. Luckily, it doesnt.

As I said in the tasting notes, it reminds me a lot of the big national pizza chains its sweet, strong enough to cut through your ingredients but not in a distracting or off-putting way. Looking at the ingredients list is downright depressing: Water, Tomato Paste, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Salt, Garlic Powder, Modified Food Starch, Onion Powder, Citric Acid, Spices.

High Fructose Corn Syrup, are you fucking kidding me? In 2021? Im ashamed this is ranking so high but blind taste tests dont lie!

Best Application:

A good all-rounder sauce, especially if youre looking to emulate those big national pizza chains.

The Bottom Line:

Punches way above its weight. If you dont want to go through the trouble of making your own dough, grab a Boboli crust and youve got two packets of perfectly serviceable sauce. Thats killing two birds with one stone.

Using Wine To Improve Store Bought Pizza Sauce

If youve cooked meat on your saucepan , theres one more truly decadent addition you can make that will really help your doctored sauce stand out: you can add red wine.The best way to do this is to pour it into the pan after youve finished cooking the meat. When this happens, the wine will deglaze your pan. This makes cleanup easier, but it also creates a mixture of wine and seared meat that is a great foundation to build your tomato sauce on.By the time your sauce is ready, the alcohol in the wine will have cooked off. The flavor it adds, though, will make your sauce even more memorable.

Also Check: Cowboy Spaghetti Pioneer Woman

Can You Buy White Pizza Sauce

Classico White Pizza Sauce delivers authentic Italian flavor to your familys favorite dishes. This white pizza sauce is a new spin on classic Italian pizza sauce recipes. Made with a perfect combination of cream, roasted garlic and other spices, this white sauce gives you homemade flavor without all of the work.

Can Ragu Be Used As Pizza Sauce

Smells Like Food in Here: Ralph

Authentic homestyle Pizza sauce with real tomatoes For a pizza to be delicious, the sauce has to be perfect. And, the Ragu Pizza sauce is as perfect as Pizza sauce could be with the right balance of tomatoes with spices to give a perfect sweet and savory flavor. The homestyle preparation is what makes it even special.

Recommended Reading: Is Rao’s Marinara Sauce Keto Friendly

Can I Use The Sauce Right Away Without Letting It Rest

Well, you could, but I wouldnt recommend it. It really is worth the wait. By waiting, it gives the seasonings time to blend together for the most robust flavors. If you are not using the sauce after 1-2 hours, store it in the refrigerator in a sealed container for up to 5 days. It makes 1 2/3 cups of sauce.

Best For Kids: Contadina Pizza Squeeze Original Pizza Sauce

Making pizza is one of the most fun family activities you can do in the kitchen, but theres a price to pay: It can be a very, very messy endeavor. This pizza sauce really shines because it comes in an easy-to-use squeeze bottle. Rather than fiddle with spoons that inevitably lead to spills, kids can get a good grip on the packaging and squeeze sauce right where it needs to be .

Its not all about convenience, though. The budget-friendly sauce tastes great, has a desirable consistency, is packaged in the USA, and is non-GMO.

Though you will spend a bit more for each jar of this pizza sauce, its worth the expense. Raos Homemade Pizza Sauce is a premium product thats a better fit than most for the health-minded consumer.

Despite being low carb and gluten-free, the slow-simmered sauce is bursting with flavors, thanks to a combination of whole peeled tomatoes and Italian cherry tomatoes, as well as olive oil, Italian spices, and a medley of fresh vegetables like carrots and onions. And, like other great sauces, the consistency is nice and thick so it spreads evenly and plentifully atop pizza dough.

Though the jar is smaller than some other comparable products, its actually a positive attributeeach jar contains just the right amount for a large sheet pan pizza. You wont be scrounging for more, and you wont have a small leftover amount that you dont know what to do with.

Recommended Reading: How To Get Tomato Sauce Out Of Fabric

Popular Recipes

More Recipes Like This