How To Make A Good Tomato Sauce

Must Try

Whats The Difference Between Italian Tomato Sauce Vs Sunday Gravy Vs Marinara Sauce

Proper Tomato Sauce Using Fresh Tomatoes (3 ingredients)
  • For Jack, an Italian Tomato Sauce is a tomato-based sauce that simmers for a long time on the stove so that the flavors really deepen and develop.
  • A Sunday Gravy recipe is a tomato sauce cooked along with a variety of meats including meatballs, spare ribs, sausage, and pork chops, so the sauce picks up additional flavor from the meat.
  • Finally, is also a tomato-based sauce, but its a quickly-cooked sauce, yielding a bright, fresh tomato flavor.
  • And since were talking about all types of tomato sauces we also have a Roasted Tomato Pizza Sauce recipe AND an Easy No-Cook Pizza Sauce recipe you might be interested in checking out too. Pizza sauces typically have a bold flavor that is meant to both complement and shine through the flavors of the dough, cheese and toppings on a pizza.

Todays recipe is originally inspired by a version of Italian Tomato Sauce that Jack grew up with, and he credits his Aunt Mary for this recipe, plus some additional influences from the sauce that Jacks father used to make. If you happen to be growing San Marzano Pomodoro tomatoes in your garden definitely use those! However, if fresh tomatoes arent available, we think some of the best San Marzano Pomodoro canned tomatoes are made by Cento and Pastene and both brands are readily available at most local grocery stores.


You may also like these other Italian family classics:

Olive Oil Is Essential For Flavor And Texture

We’re getting a bit ahead of ourselves here though. Before you can add your tomatoes to the pot, you have to start with oil. Oil serves a number of different functions in a sauce. First and foremost, it’s a flavor transfer medium. By sautéing aromatics like garlic in oil you break down its cell structure, releasing flavorful compounds, many of which are fat-soluble. These fat soluble compounds then work their way throughout the sauce.

Oil also allows you to cook at higher temperatures and is less volatile than, say, water. Many chemical reactions that create flavor don’t occur under the 212°F boiling point of water. Oil is an edible medium which can be heated well above this temperature. Finally, fat adds flavor and texture of its own. Some folks will tell you that you should never cook with extra-virgin olive oil, as it ruins its flavor. Poppycock!

Yes it’s true that some of its flavors will break down. But then again, a neutral oil like canola or vegetable has pretty much zero flavor to begin with. You do the math. Or let me just do it for you: A Lot > Some > None. Sauces made with good olive oil will have noticeably better flavor than those made with neutral oil. And, of course, it doesn’t hurt to drizzle some fresh olive oil in at the end as well.

Good olive oil does run the risk of burning and turning acrid if you heat it too much, and particularly when using sediment-heavy olive oils. When making a sauce like this, though, you’re never at risk of the oil smoking .

A Short Ingredient List

Many of the tomato sauce recipes in this realm include all sorts of ingredients. One camp likes to kick things off by browning onions and ground beef for a chunky stew-like sauce, others love to use carrots and celery and all manner of dusty dried herbs and seasonings. This recipe is going to be on the absolute other end of the spectrum – in all the best ways. You wouldn’t wear a wool coat to the beach, right? That’s what heavy spaghetti and tomato sauces in warm weather feel like to me. This sauce is a relatively pure expression of tomatoes accented with a bit of edge from crushed red peppers, a hint of garlic, and my secret ingredient – a touch of lemon zest which brings its citrus aroma and a bit of surprise to the party.

Read Also: Can You Buy Chick Fil A Honey Roasted Bbq Sauce

How Not To Serve Pasta

Also, if youve been plating pasta in a bowl, then topping it with sauce like the emoji , this is American-style. It honestly doesnt taste as good if served this way. Youre welcome!

If you want to serve it the way they do in Italy, mix the sauce in with the pasta and then plate it. Domenica Marchetti, who is an authority on Italian cuisine and the author of six Italian cookbooks explains this on her site, also. If youll notice, she also has a simple Italian tomato sauce recipe which is almost identical to mine.


Dont miss another post! Sign up for my free subscription at the bottom of this post

Which Herbs Add The Most Flavor To Tomato Sauce

How to make Basic Tomato Sauce Recipe

The question of herbs is always a divisive one. Fresh or dried? Parsley? Oregano? Basil?

I tried a number of iterations using fresh and dried versions of each in various combinations. I ended up settling on a mix of dried oregano and fresh basil leaves and stems.

As it turns out, some herbs are better dried than others. Basil and parsley both taste terrible in their dried formslike papery, bland shadows of themselves. Oregano, on the other hand, fares just fine. The flavor is a little different from fresh oregano, but it’s intense and herbal in its own way, and for my money, is an indispensable element of a good Italian-American red sauce.

Why the discrepancy between the herbs? The difference mainly comes down to how the particular herbs grow. Basil and parsley both have thin, delicate leaves and grow in environments where there is plentiful water and little chance of the leaves completely drying out. Heartier herbs from drier climateslike oregano, marjoram, or rosemaryon the other hand, are far more robust. As a consequence, the aromatic compounds within those herbs also tend to be less volatile so that the plants can retain them even as they lose moisture to the atmosphere.

The end result, as far as we cooks are concerned, is that those heartier herbs from drier places can hold onto their flavor far better when dried than tender leafy herbs.

Serious Eats

Serious Eats

Also Check: Raos Keto

Splash In A Bit Of Red Wine

Just a tablespoon or two of whatever is open should work. There are two ways to do this: you can just pour in a tiny bit while stirring or its a step you can take while sautéing garlic you add a splash of that Pinot and let it deglaze the plan before stirring in the sauce.

Oh, and dont worry about the kids any more than youd worry about adding some vanilla extract. No one is gong to get drunk.

How Do You Make Fresh Tomato Sauce

Its not difficult at all, and youll be so happy with the results .

This is a super quick Italian pasta sauce recipe which is actually ready by the time the pasta is done . You can choose to make a smooth or chunky sauce according to the tomatoes you use. Just remember, there should be no need to add any sugar, not even a pinch! Yes, it cuts the acidity, but if you use the right tomatoes, there is no acidity!

You may also like to make homemade gnocchi and serve it with this sauce.

This is also a base for many other types of sauces, including penne alla vodka and penne arrabbiata. If you want to add both onion and garlic to this sauce, you may, but Id suggest making it as written the first time.

Read Also: Where To Buy Rao’s Pasta Sauce

How To Make Authentic Italian Tomato Sauce

A around 1 tablespoon of olive oil to a medium sized saucepan, once it starts to sizzle add chopped garlic and dried oregano. Fry for 30 seconds then add 1 teaspoon of balsamic vinegar and freshly chopped parsley and basil .

Fry the herbs and garlic for another 30 seconds then add a can of chopped tomatoes with ½ teaspoon sugar and a pinch of salt. Add 2 tablespoon of water to the empty tomato can, swirl to get as much leftover tomato as possible and add that to the sauce .

Stir everything together, after 1 minute use a potato masher to crush the tomatoes and break them down as much as possible then simmer for 7-8 minutes stirring occasionally, turn off the heat and check for seasoning .

How Not To Make Tomato Sauce Read On

Best Italian Tomato PASTA SAUCE RECIPE
  • USE FRESH TOMATOES WHEN THEYRE IN SEASON. Who can argue with that? However, Buzzfeed is completely off-base in giving advice on which fresh tomatoes are good to use for sauce and which are bad. Roma and beefsteak tomatoes are listed as being good for sauce, when in fact, Romas are good and beefsteak are in fact better for salads. Buzzfeed also claims heirloom and cherry tomatoes are bad for sauce, but what is so interesting to me, are the reasons for stating these tomatoes are bad for sauce: heirlooms are just too expensive to use for sauce. Well, I happen to know that many people actually grow their own heirloom tomatoes and sometimes have too many to eat fresh. The piece also advises that cherry tomatoes are bad because they will take forever to peel because theyre so small And they dont have much flesh anyway. Here goes my blood pressure again: good-quality cherry tomatoes can make a fabulous sauce! Next, the instructions state, You will need to peel and crush them. Here we go again, I dont recall any rule or law stating that I have to peel my tomatoes in order to make sauce. First of all, why must tomatoes be peeled? I happen to like getting extra nutrition whenever possible, and eating the tomato skin is a good thing . I for one, refuse to peel my tomatoes. Oh, and BuzzFeed, heres a tip: a 6 step tutorial in step one of a recipe, does not bode well if you actually want cooks to stick around until the very end of the recipe.
  • You May Like: How Many Scovilles Is Texas Pete Hot Sauce

    When Should You Peel Tomatoes For A Recipe

    You will want to peel your tomatoes any time you’re looking for a completely smooth texture preparing a hot soup or stew or tomato sauce, for example. A lot of this comes down to preference, though. You do not need to peel your tomatoes if you don’t mind the skins.

    Alternatively, if you don’t want to go through the effort of peeling tomatoes, you can always purchase a can of whole peeled tomatoes to minimize this step. But if you want to make a dish that highlights fresh, peak-season tomatoes, such as salsa or gazpacho, peeling is the way to go.

    Karishma Pradhan

    How To Make Homemade Tomato Sauce

    Let’s get saucy! There are three basic styles of tomato sauces:

    1. Long simmering tomato-based pasta sauces achieve a rich, complex flavor.

    2. Barely cooked tomato sauces have a lighter flavor more recognizable of fresh tomatoes, but a little bit of cooking softens the tomatoes and brings out their sweetness.

    3. Uncooked sauces are bright and refreshing, and are best made with thoroughly ripe summer tomatoes.

    Recommended Reading: Rao’s Homemade Marinara Sauce Stores

    Why Is This The Best Marinara Sauce

    Six reasons to love this recipe:

    • This marinara sauce recipe requires 5 basic ingredients and yields rich, authentic marinara flavor.
    • Its super easy to makeno chopping required.
    • Unlike most store-bought sauces, this marinara is free of added sugar.
    • You can load up your pasta with as much of this wholesome sauce as youd like. Tomatoes are good for you!
    • The recipe yields two cups of sauce and freezes well, so you might as well double the recipe. Just cook it in a bigger pot.
    • This marinara also makes an incredible pizza sauce. I made pizza with it and my friend remarked that it tastes like real-deal Italian pizza.

    Please let me know in the comments how you like this sauce! Its a new staple in my kitchen, and I hope it becomes a go-to recipe for you as well.

    Craving more classic Italian recipes? Dont miss these:

    What Is A Mother Sauce In Cooking

    Learn how to make incredibly easy homemade tomato sauce, then use it in ...

    A basic sauce that serves as a base sauce to use in making other variations of the original sauce. Initially perfected by the French, all sauces are now universally categorized into one of 5 groups of sauces serving as a base or foundation for others sauces and referred to as the Grand or Mother Sauces.

    Recommended Reading: Gout Tomatoes Good Or Bad

    Our Favorite Ways To Serve It Up:

    I hope you love this homemade tomato sauce just as much as we do! Its a staple for complimenting my favorite Italian recipes especially around the holidays.

    Serve with your favorite crusty french bread for perfection!

    If youre looking for a red sauce made with fresh tomatoes youll love our Fresh Tomato Sauce recipe!

    Got Pinterest? Pin this recipe to your Pinterest boards!

    If you tried this San Marzano Tomato Sauce recipe or any other recipe, dont forget to rate the recipe and let me know what you think. I love hearing from you! You can also follow me on , , and for more crave-worthy content.

    The Perfect Tomato Sauce

    800g good, tinned plum tomatoes or ripe fresh fruit2 tbsp olive oil1 small onion, finely chopped2 garlic cloves, crushed3 stems of fresh basilExtra-virgin oil, to serve

    If using fresh tomatoes, drop them into a pan of boiling water and leave for about a minute, until the skins split. Lift out and peel, then roughly chop.

    Heat the oil in a medium saucepan on a medium-low heat and add the chopped onion. Soften for about five to seven minutes, until translucent but not coloured. Stir in the garlic and cook for another two minutes.

    Tip in the tomatoes, and break up with a wooden spoon if necessary, then add the sugar, vinegar and the stems of the basil, reserving the leaves. Season lightly.

    Bring to a simmer, then turn down the heat and simmer for 45 minutes, stirring occasionally, until thick.

    Test the seasoning, add the basil leaves, roughly torn, and drizzle in a little extra-virgin olive oil if you like before serving.

    Tomato sauce: laughably basic cookery, or harder than it looks, especially in the UK? And what special twist do you give yours? Non-Italian variations particularly welcome.

    Felicity Cloake’s perfect tomato sauce.

    Don’t Miss: Heatonist Subscription

    Why Are San Marzano Tomatoes The Best

    San Marzano tomatoes first originated in Naples, Italy. They are not just a staple in my familys recipes, but are considered to be the best tomatoes in the world to use in sauces!

    These tomatoes are set apart from others because of their rich, sweet flavor and lower acidity. They are also known to have a thicker consistency compared to other canned plum tomatoes.

    Take an extra step and use DOP-certified tomatoes usually visible on the front or the back of the can. This is a protective seal that guarantees authenticity.

    How To Freeze Homemade Tomato Sauce

    How to make… Basic Tomato Sauce!

    Freeze for up to 3 months in a freezer-safe zipper bag or container, making sure to leave room for expansion as it freezes. Tomato sauce can stain plastic containers so if you choose to freeze in a plastic container, make sure it’s one you don’t mind getting stained.

    Thaw in the refrigerator overnight, or thaw on the stovetop on medium low heat, stirring occasionally.

    Don’t Miss: Tomato Bad For Gout

    Fighting A Losing Battle

    One of the biggest reasons that I spend countless hours on my blog is to encourage people of all ages to get into the kitchen and cook healthy, unprocessed meals. I also want them to realize that many healthy, delicious meals and basic recipes do not take a lot of time and effort, expensive ingredients or specialized equipment. This BuzzFeed article has probably managed to scare off scores of potential cooks from ever wanting to attempt to make homemade sauce, and that upsets me. A lot. Facebook commenter Dan Holley says it best,

    Im okay with store-bought tasting a bit inferior if it means I can bypass the 10 steps, 486 hours and dozen-or-so culinary devices required to make this sauce. :/

    I love to cook, even lengthy and complicated recipes at times, and theres no chance in hell that I would ever make tomato sauce again if this was the only recipe I could use.

    I realize that writing this is not the most politically correct thing to do, but I feel so strongly about saving authentic Italian cuisine from extinction, that Ive decided that this is something I must do. Nonno and Nonna would be proud of me, and thats what matters the most to me.

    Time for another DEEP BREATH.

    Are you ready for BuzzFeeds 12 steps to the Best Tomato Sauce? Id rather do the other 12 step Program to tell you the truth, but this has to be done. First, Ill list BuzzFeeds instructions in caps, then Ill add my rebuttal, and let you form your own opinions from there.

    Easy Homemade Tomato Sauce

    This recipe for Easy Homemade Tomato Sauce shows how to make spaghetti sauce from scratch right in your own kitchen.

    Serve with pasta and a side of warm Homemade Garlic Bread for an easy weeknight dinner everyone will enjoy!

    This easy homemade pasta sauce is super simple to make and tastes so much better than store-bought ever could!

    Simply saute onions, garlic carrots and celery in a pan, adding tomatoes, seasoning, and fresh herbs its that easy!

    Recommended Reading: Campbell’s Oven Sauces Creamy Garlic Butter Chicken

    Popular Recipes

    More Recipes Like This