Sweet Baby Ray’s Buffalo Sauce Recipe

Must Try

How To Make Crispy Chicken Wings In The Oven

GoWISE USA Air Fryer – Buffalo Chicken Wings with Sweet Baby Ray’s Wing Sauce

Theres a couple of tips that we have for making seriously crispy, oven baked chicken wings. The first step is to make sure your wings are really dry. Grab a bunch of paper towels and dry them as much as you can before adding the seasoning.

The next step is to season the chicken wings. The seasonings are pretty basic except for one special ingredient.

Baking Powder. Baking powder helps crisp this chicken wing recipe up in the oven for the best results. Of course frying your chicken wings will produce the most crispy chicken wings, and were not opposed to fried food once in a while!

But for the every day meal, a crispy oven baked chicken wings will do.

After you toss the chicken wings in the seasoning, place them on a wire rack over a baking sheet so that the air circulates all around the wings, not just on the top and the sides.

Spray the baking rack with cooking spray first so that the wings dont stick to them as they bake. You can also coat the baking sheet with aluminum foil to make cleaning up even easier.

Sweet Baby Rays Kickin Bourbon Wing Sauce & Glaze

Finally, the BBQ version of their wing sauce.

Smooth bourbon, sticky molasses and spicy peppers

Ingredients:water, high fructose corn syrup, aged cayenne pepper, molasses, distilled vinegar, modified food starch, salt, contains less than 2% of: bourbon, dried garlic, chipotle pepper, spice, natural flavor, potassium sorbate and sodium benzoate as preservatives, xanthan gum, tomato paste, paprika, sucralose, citric acid, sodium citrate.

Texture and Appearance: Dark almost mahogany colored. This mildly thick sauce is the BBQ Wing sauce king of the bunch. It clings nicely to the wings. Classic bbq.

Taste on wings: This is a BBQ wing. Make no mistake about it. Superior to your average bar bbq wing, these are very satisfying and tasty. Winner.

Overall rating:

Heat Level: 2 stars Heat is just under medium here. This is all about the BBQ wing. Classy.

Satisfaction: 3 stars Almost tops on our preference for a bbq wing. Delicious and savory. Preferred.

Disclaimer: We purchased this product for our own personal use and review purposes. No compensation was received. The thoughts and opinions expressed are our own.

More Week of Wings 5

Copycat Sweet Baby Rays Bbq Sauce Ingredients:

There are quite a few ingredients for our copycat Sweet Baby Rays BBQ Sauce recipe, but they are still pretty simple and easy to find:

  • 1 1/4 cups ketchup
  • 1 cup dark brown sugar
  • 1/4 cup molasses
  • 1 tablespoon hickory liquid smoke
  • 2 1/2 teaspoons ground mustard
  • 2 teaspoons paprika
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons kosher salt
  • 1 teaspoon black pepper
  • 1 tablespoon cornstarch dissolved in 1/8 cup cold water

Here are some kitchen supplies I recommend with this recipe:

Recommended Reading: Where Can I Buy Rao’s Sauce

Sweet Baby Rays Sweet Chili Buffalo And Kickin Bourbon Wing Sauces

Week of Wings 5 Day 4. Our featured wings today are a 3 way from Sweet Baby Rays. Sweet Chili Wing Sauce and Glaze, Buffalo Wing Sauce and Glaze, and Kickin Bourbon Wing Sauce and Glaze. All are easily found on your local grocers shelves.

We like Sweet Baby Rays BBQ sauces who doesnt? I would venture to say they are probably Americas favorite store-bought sauces. But how do their wing sauces hold up? The Sauce is The Boss as they say.

Preparation: Deep fried. Again, we did our usual 3 step cook baked at 350º for 40 minutes , deep fried at 350 375º for 2 3 minutes, then tossed in the sauce. See our Wings 101 post for more info.

Sweet Baby Rays Sweet Chili Wing Sauce & Glaze

Sweet Baby Ray

First up, is their Sweet Chili sauce.

This sauce starts off sweet, but spicy red chili peppers provide enough heat to fire up an order of wings or liven up grilled salmon, popcorn shrimp, or pork chips.

Ingredients:high fructose corn syrup, distilled vinegar, aged cayenne pepper, water, modified food starch, salt, sugar, contains less than 2% of: sriracha chile sauce, red bell pepper, garlic, wheat, soybeans, vegetable oil, chicken base, spice, chile de arbol pepper, potassium sorbate, sodium benzoate, sodium metabisulfite as preservatives, xanthan gum, paprika.

Texture and Appearance: Typical thick and sticky chile sauce, with bits of ingredients floating about. Clean.

Taste on wings: Super sweet and very sticky. Finger licking goodness with just a touch of heat. Enjoyable.

Overall rating:

Heat Level: . Just a tingle of heat. Ultra mild.

Satisfaction: 1 Star We think these wings are acceptable. And we think this sauce would make a great crockpot full of meatballs , or added to baked beans, or as a glaze on ham or pork.

Read Also: Texas Pete Hot Wings

Why Not Just Buy Sweet Baby Rays Bbq Sauce From The Store

Well, because being able to make your favorite food products at home is awesome! There is power in knowing the ingredients and being able to make your own adjustments.

You can avoid ingredients that may not be good for you, like artificial colors and preservatives, and its also really helpful for people with food allergies or sensitivities. On top of all that, youll save money by making your own sauce!

Now dont get me wrong, we like Original Sweet Baby Rays Barbecue Sauce around here. There are often coupons and sales on for Sweet Baby Rays too so I can get it at a good price. However, it contains high fructose corn syrup, artificial coloring, and a preservative. I definitely ingest my fair share of such ingredients, but its is nice to reduce or avoid them when I can.

Sweet Baby Rays Buffalo Wing Sauce & Glaze

Next up, their version of Buffalo Wing Sauce.

full flavored sauce with the perfect blend of cayenne pepper and garlic, and a rich butter finish.

Ingredients:aged cayenne pepper, distilled vinegar, margarine, water, salt, dried garlic, contains less than 2% of: vegetable oil, paprika, xanthan gum, propylene glycol alginate, citric acid. Gluten free.

Texture and Appearance: Thin and bright orange in color. Were back to the typical buffalo style bottled sauce look here. Moderately clingy and sets up on the wings. Great cling factor.

Taste on wings: This has all the taste of a very traditional wing from your local bar. Not a lot of butter taste, and the vinegar flavor is very mild. The taste is average, and the heat only slightly hotter than other bottled sauces from the store. Tangy.

Overall rating:

Heat Level: Hotter than some store sauces, but only at a bare minimum. Would make for an acceptable wing that everyone could enjoy. Nice quality of flavor. Reliable.

Satisfaction: 2 Stars Nothing wrong with these mild wings. Theyre just what you would imagine from a bar with a decent mild wing. Average.

You May Like: Where To Buy Rao’s Marinara Sauce

Sweet Baby Rays Chicken

Chicken has never been better than when you use Sweet Baby Rays sauces to make the best easy chicken you will ever eat! The recipe is simple but delicious!

I love Sweet Baby Rays BBQ Sauce but have you tried their other sauces? WOW there are some that are super good! This recipe uses not just one sauce but three Sweet Baby Rays Sauces. The flavor is amazing for this grilled, baked or smoked chicken and the recipe is super easy. Giving you an easy chicken marinade and sauce for the best chicken you will ever eat!

DISCLAIMER: I am not getting paid to promote or use Sweet Baby Rays Sauces. The name for this recipe is used because it uses 3 Sweet Baby Rays Sauces !

The Three Sweet Baby Ray Sauces

AIR FRIED CAULIFLOWER BUFFALO Sweet Baby Rays Creamy Wings Sauce

The three Sweet Baby Rays Sauces I use blend together perfectly. I use Sweet Baby Rays Sweet Teriyaki Sauce, Sweet Baby Rays Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce, and Sweet Baby Rays Buffalo Wing Sauce.

These 3 sauces come together to make the most amazing sauce for your chicken. The sauce is sweet, with a tangy note and a bit of heat. You can adjust the amount of each sauce to your liking.

You May Like: Rao’s Homemade Marinara Sauce Where To Buy

Crispy Baked Buffalo Chicken Wings

Crispy Baked Buffalo Chicken Wings are SO addicting and fall off the bone tender! Our cooking tips make them as crispy as if you fried them!

Love wings? Weve got a TON of chicken wing recipes for you to check out! Like these Slow Cooker Sweet Chili Chicken Wings and these Crispy Baked Garlic Parmesan Chicken Wings.

How To Make Beef And Chorizo Red Picadillo Tacos

Rach is an upstate girl, so Buffalo wings and lets be real: anything Buffalo-flavored are near and dear to her heart. There’s a reason why we have recipes for Buffalo chicken dips, Buffalo chicken sandwiches, Buffalo mac & cheese, Buffalo quesadillas, Buffalo pot pie, and more! You get the idea.

Buffalo wings are the classic, and when faced with a plateful, we don’t know anyone who can resist these deep-fried, saucy snacks. But why stop there? Once you understand the flavor profile behind Buffalo sauce, youll be able to apply it to a wide range of foods, from grilled veggies to tofu to frogs legs .

To turn your kitchen into a full-on Buffalo zone, youll need a great marinade and a classic sauce. Were here to hook you up with both!


Our favorite Buffalo wing recipe comes from our culinary producer Grant Melton, who likes to start his ultimate Buffalo wings off with a marinade. If youre looking to infuse any type of meat with Buffalo goodness, a marinade will give you a strong foundation.

To whip up your own Buffalo marinade, youll need:

  • Buttermilk
  • Dried dill
  • Salt and pepper

Mix those ingredients together and marinade the wings for at least 2 hours and up to 24 hours before cooking


To make a Buffalo sauce, youll need:

  • Hot sauce
  • Butter

Read Also: Rao Pasta Sauce Where To Buy

Can You Make Buffalo Chicken Wings Ahead Of Time

These Baked Buffalo Chicken Wings are really best when they are first made, but I do have a way you can get them done a little bit ahead of time if you need to.

Season and bake the wings but take them out 10 minutes before they are done cooking. Store the chicken wings in the refrigerator until about a half an hour before you need them. Bring the wings out of the refrigerator and let them come to room temperature while the oven heats up.

Now bake the chicken for the remaining 10 minutes then toss them in the buffalo sauce.

If you cook and and toss the wings in the buffalo wing sauce and then cool and reheat the wings will be softer and definitely not crispy, so try serving them right away or using the cooking method I described here.

Now its time to eat! Serve these wings with Ranch or Blue Cheese dressing for dipping and even some celery and carrot sticks on the side.

We LOVE serving these buffalo chicken wings for appetizers or the main meal. Obviously if youre serving these for dinner youll want to make sure you have a few more wings per person, so make sure you have enough!


How To Make Your Own Sweet Baby Rays Bbq Sauce

Sweet Baby Rays Wings 3 Ways

This Sweet Baby Rays BBQ sauce copycat recipe really does taste just like Sweet Baby Rays Original sauce! I did a side-by-side taste test to make sure! This sauce is perfect for grilled chicken, barbecue chicken pizza, ribs, beans, dipping nuggets, pulled pork, salad, and basically whatever you desire.

Also Check: Costco Rao’s Marinara Sauce

Serving Sweet Baby Rays Chicken

After your chicken has cooked it is time to eat! I always make some extra sauce/marinade for dipping.

We love to have some grilled garlic bread, corn on the cob, a loaded baked potato and a side salad with this chicken.

This chicken is also great in sandwiches, or wraps!

For some other meaty recipes try my : Whole Chicken on The Smoker, or my Tri-Tip on The Smoker.

Check out my latest posts:

Sweet Baby Rays Buffalo Wings

Ive been using Sweet Baby Rays barbecue sauce for years. Its a great sauce as-is, but it also makes for a good starter for making my own BBQ sauce. But until now Id never tried their Buffalo wing sauce. For some reason, I needed a coupon to get me off my butt and to the grocery store to pick up a bottle. Well, boy am I sorry for having waited so long to try it. This sauce makes for the perfect Buffalo wings. It is exactly what I was looking for when I made a quick batch of air fryer wings for lunch the other day. The right consistency, the right amount of spice, its spot-on good.

Ive read a few reviews of Sweet Baby Rays Buffalo wing sauce that say its too spicy. Well, yeah, each of us have a different definition of whats spicy, but I definitely found this to be just right. It has a bit of kick. Hey, its a Buffalo wing sauce. It contains cayenne pepper. Its gonna have some heat. But for me, its definitely not over the top.

Dont wait around for a coupon to pick up a bottle of this sauce. Learn from my mistakes!

Also Check: Raos Sauce Where To Buy

Bake In Oven On 350 For About 20 Minutes

Sweet baby rays recipes chicken baked. Arrange the wings on a plate with celery sticks. Put chicken in an 8×8 casserole dish. Got a recipe of your own.

8 boneless skinless chicken breasts. Drizzle the sauce onto the wings and gently toss to coat. Sweet baby rays sweet spicy barbecue sausage and peppers mostaccioli.

Baked sweet potato fries with green chili sriracha aioli. Submit your own recipe. Ingredients 1 cup sweet baby rays barbecue sauce.

Sweet raby rays smoked chicken texas style buffalo chicken flatbread. 6 8 servings recipe adapted from heather loves food. Honey hot southern fried chicken.

With sweet baby rays hot sauce. Take the bacon. Bake for 30 35 minutes turning over halfway through cooking time until the wings are crispy.

Theyre served best with a baked potato make mine a yam a tossed salad. 10 min prep 1 hour marinading 50 60 min cooking yield. The rest is bone fat and cartiledge.

Mash down the potato to make room for this chicken. Serve with additional buffalo sauce if desired and ranch dressing. With sweet baby rays original barbecue sauce.

Oven baked bbq chicken print recipe. Directions oven bake 45 minutes or microwave 5 minutes a sweet potato until tender. Shred a cooked chicken breast with a fork and add to a hot saute pan.

Hot mac and cheese bites. Contributed by sweet baby rays. 12 cup diced onion pepper to taste.

Submit it now. 12 cup dijon mustard. So of the 2 packs of ribs where the combined weight is 260 oz.

Contributed by sweet baby rays.

Tips For Making Baked Chicken Wings Crispy

Sweet Baby Rays Buffalo Sauce Review Inferno Wing Roulette!

Now were going to talk about another tip for getting crispy, oven baked chicken wings, the oven temperature. You need a pretty hot oven here, were not cooking low and slow. Were cooking high and fast.

So the oven temperature is going to be 425 degrees, you can also turn the oven up to 450 degrees during the last 5 minutes of cooking to get an extra brown, crisp coating.

Read Also: Where To Buy Rao Marinara Sauce

Popular Recipes

More Recipes Like This